32 Books Like Icebreaker by Hannah Grace
So, I know you devoured Icebreaker by Hannah Grace like I did, and now you’re probably on the hunt for something that hits those same vibes.
Honestly, Icebreaker was such a fun mix of romance, sports, and characters you can’t help but root for. I get why you’re craving more of that magic.
Lucky for you, I’ve got a list of some books that’ll scratch that itch perfectly. Each one brings something a little different to the table, but they all have that addictive charm that Icebreaker does.
Let’s dive in!
Books Like Icebreaker
1. The Deal by Elle Kennedy
Okay, you’ve probably heard of The Deal because it’s a total classic in the college sports romance genre.
If you haven’t read it yet, now’s the time. This book is the first in the Off-Campus series, and it’s all about Hannah Wells and Garrett Graham.
Hannah is smart and focused on her studies, but she’s got a crush on a guy who doesn’t know she exists.
Garrett, the college hockey team’s captain, is struggling in class and needs a tutor.
They strike a deal: she’ll tutor him, and he’ll help her get the attention of her crush. What starts as a deal, obviously, turns into something way more.
You’ll love the banter, the chemistry, and the way the romance slowly builds. Plus, Garrett is the perfect blend of cocky and sweet.
2. The Chase by Elle Kennedy
Since you liked Icebreaker, I think you’ll really enjoy The Chase, which is also by Elle Kennedy but part of her Briar U series.
This one follows Summer Di Laurentis, a fashionista with a big personality, and Colin Fitzgerald, a tattooed, introverted hockey player.
They’re total opposites, which makes their dynamic super interesting. Summer moves in with Colin and his teammates, and sparks start flying.
The tension between them is electric, and you’ll get that same fun mix of romance and sports that you loved in Icebreaker.
3. The Wall of Winnipeg and Me by Mariana Zapata
Now, if you’re into slow-burn romance, The Wall of Winnipeg and Me is going to be right up your alley.
This book is all about Aiden Graves, a professional football player, and Vanessa Mazur, his assistant.
Vanessa is ready to quit her job and move on, but Aiden asks her to stay and proposes something unexpected—a marriage of convenience.
The story takes its time, really letting you sink into the characters and their evolving relationship.
It’s intense, emotional, and deeply satisfying when things finally come together. Plus, the sports element gives it that extra edge you’re looking for.
4. Pucked by Helena Hunting
If you liked the humor and the strong personalities in Icebreaker, then Pucked by Helena Hunting is a must-read.
This book is hilarious and has a lot of heart. It follows Violet Hall, who’s a bit of a quirky, outspoken girl, and Alex Waters, a professional hockey player who’s got a bit of a reputation.
Their chemistry is off the charts, and the banter between them is laugh-out-loud funny.
It’s a light-hearted read with just the right amount of drama, and the romance is super steamy. Definitely one for your list if you want something fun and sexy.
5. Him by Sarina Bowen and Elle Kennedy
If you’re open to a male/male romance, Him is an amazing choice.
It’s co-written by Sarina Bowen and Elle Kennedy (yep, Elle Kennedy again—she’s that good), and it’s about two hockey players, Jamie Canning and Ryan Wesley, who reconnect after a few years apart.
They were best friends at hockey camp, but something happened that caused a rift between them. When they meet again, old feelings resurface, and things get complicated.
The romance is sweet, tender, and full of heart. Plus, the hockey setting keeps that sporty vibe going strong.
6. The Risk by Elle Kennedy
Alright, one more Elle Kennedy recommendation because, honestly, she’s the queen of sports romance.
The Risk is part of the Briar U series, and it focuses on Brenna Jensen, the daughter of a hockey coach, and Jake Connelly, a star player from a rival team.
Brenna’s got a tough exterior and doesn’t fall for just anyone, but Jake is determined to win her over.
The back-and-forth between them is electric, and the stakes are high with the whole rival team dynamic.
You’ll get all the tension, drama, and swoon-worthy moments you could want.
7. The Hook Up by Kristen Callihan
The Hook Up is another college sports romance, but this one’s got a slightly different vibe.
It’s about Anna Jones, who’s determined to keep her head down and finish college without any drama, and Drew Baylor, the star quarterback who’s used to getting whatever he wants.
Drew sets his sights on Anna, and she tries to resist, but their chemistry is undeniable.
What I love about this book is that it goes deep into the characters’ insecurities and fears, making their connection feel really authentic.
It’s sexy, emotional, and totally captivating.
8. The Play by Karina Halle
If you’re in the mood for a rugby romance, The Play by Karina Halle is a great pick.
The story follows Lachlan McGregor, a brooding, intense rugby player, and Kayla Moore, a woman trying to make a fresh start.
Lachlan has a troubled past and is all about focusing on his career, but when he meets Kayla, his priorities start to shift.
This book has a great mix of angst, passion, and humor, and the slow build between the characters makes their romance that much more satisfying.
It’s a bit darker and more intense than Icebreaker, but just as addictive.
9. Kulti by Mariana Zapata
Another Mariana Zapata book because she’s the queen of slow-burn romance.
Kulti is about Sal Casillas, a professional soccer player, and her new coach, Reiner Kulti, who happens to be her childhood idol.
The problem? Kulti is a total jerk—or at least that’s how he comes across at first.
The tension between them is palpable, and as they start to get to know each other, the walls start to come down.
This book is a masterclass in character development, and by the time the romance really takes off, you’ll be completely invested. It’s a slow build, but the payoff is worth it.
10. A Lie for a Lie by Helena Hunting
Let’s circle back to Helena Hunting with A Lie for a Lie. This one’s got a bit of a different setup—it’s about Rook Bowman, a professional hockey player, who has a whirlwind romance with a woman he meets on vacation.
They lose touch, but when they cross paths again, Rook realizes he’s been keeping some big secrets.
This book has a nice mix of humor, emotion, and drama, and the romance is both sweet and sexy.
It’s got that same blend of fun and heart that you found in Icebreaker, and you’ll love watching the characters find their way back to each other.
11. The Score by Elle Kennedy
We’re diving back into Elle Kennedy’s world because she just knows how to write these sports romances!
The Score is part of the Off-Campus series and follows Allie Hayes, who’s just gone through a rough breakup, and Dean Di Laurentis, the ultimate playboy of the hockey team.
Allie wants to forget her ex, and Dean seems like the perfect distraction.
But what starts as a one-night stand quickly becomes something neither of them expected.
This book is fun, sexy, and full of that banter we all love. Plus, Dean’s charm is absolutely irresistible.
12. Play With Me by Kristen Proby
Play With Me is a delightful sports romance set in Seattle, focusing on NFL quarterback Will Montgomery and the independent, no-nonsense Meg McBride.
Will is used to getting what he wants, and when he sets his sights on Meg, he’s determined to win her over.
But Meg has her reasons for keeping her distance, and Will has to work hard to prove he’s not just another cocky athlete.
The chemistry between them is electric, and the push-and-pull dynamic will keep you hooked from start to finish. It’s sweet, steamy, and full of heart.
13. Hooked by Brenna Aubrey
In Hooked, we follow Liam Callahan, a professional golfer trying to make a comeback, and Kate McIntyre, a former Olympic swimmer turned sports psychologist.
Liam’s career is on the line, and Kate’s there to help him get back on track. But as they work together, their professional relationship starts to blur into something more.
This book offers a unique sports setting with golf, which you don’t see as often, and the dynamic between the characters is full of tension and chemistry.
If you liked the focus on personal growth and romance in Icebreaker, you’ll enjoy this one.
14. Rookie Move by Sarina Bowen
Sarina Bowen knows her way around a hockey romance, and Rookie Move is a fantastic example.
This book kicks off the Brooklyn Bruisers series and centers on Leo Trevi, a hockey player who’s just been called up to the NHL, and Georgia Worthington, the team’s PR manager—who also happens to be his ex-girlfriend.
The history between Leo and Georgia adds an extra layer of depth to their romance, and you’ll be rooting for them to find their way back to each other.
It’s a second-chance romance with plenty of heat and heart, wrapped up in a hockey setting.
15. Scoring Wilder by R.S. Grey
If you’re in the mood for a fun, light-hearted sports romance, Scoring Wilder is perfect.
It follows Kinsley Bryant, a college soccer star, and Liam Wilder, her new coach, who also happens to be a professional soccer player and a major heartthrob.
The attraction between them is instant, but there’s one big problem: coach-player relationships are off-limits. The forbidden aspect adds some great tension, and Kinsley’s witty, relatable narration will keep you laughing throughout.
It’s the perfect mix of humor, romance, and sports drama.
16. The Locker Room by Meghan Quinn
The Locker Room is a hilarious and heartwarming sports romance about Knox Gentry, a college baseball star, and Emory, the girl who’s sworn off dating athletes.
Knox is determined to change her mind, and his charm, persistence, and sense of humor make it hard for Emory to resist.
This book has that college romance vibe with plenty of playful banter, steamy moments, and a strong focus on friendships.
It’s a feel-good read that’ll leave you with a big smile on your face.
17. A Favor for a Favor by Helena Hunting
We’re back with Helena Hunting, this time with A Favor for a Favor, part of her All In series.
The story follows Stevie, who’s just moved in with her brother, an NHL player, after a bad breakup, and Bishop, her brother’s grumpy, injured teammate.
When Stevie offers to help Bishop with his recovery, they strike up an unexpected friendship that slowly turns into something more.
The enemies-to-lovers dynamic is done perfectly here, with lots of snark, chemistry, and slow-burn tension.
If you love romances where the characters start off on the wrong foot but eventually find common ground, this one’s for you.
18. Until It Fades by K.A. Tucker
Until It Fades is a bit different from the others on this list—it’s more of a slow-burn romance with a focus on character development and emotional depth.
The story follows Catherine Wright, a single mother with a troubled past, and Brett Madden, a professional hockey player whose life she saves after a car accident.
Their connection is instant but complicated, and the romance builds slowly as they navigate their very different lives.
It’s a beautifully written story with a lot of heart, and the sports element adds an interesting layer to the narrative.
19. Playing for Keeps by Kendall Ryan
Playing for Keeps is a fun, flirty sports romance about Justin Brady, a pro hockey player, and Elise Parrish, his best friend’s little sister.
Elise has had a crush on Justin forever, but she’s always been off-limits. When a night of unexpected passion throws their friendship into chaos, Justin and Elise have to figure out what they really want.
The best-friend’s-sister trope is done really well here, and the chemistry between Justin and Elise is off the charts.
It’s a light, sexy read with plenty of humor and heart.
20. Intercepted by Alexa Martin
Intercepted by Alexa Martin is a fresh and fun take on the sports romance genre.
The story follows Marlee Harper, who’s been dating an NFL player for years, only to find out he’s been cheating on her.
When she decides to move on with her life, she crosses paths with Gavin Pope, the team’s new quarterback and her ex’s rival.
Gavin’s determined to win Marlee over, but she’s not so sure about dating another football player.
This book is packed with sass, humor, and a strong, relatable heroine. It’s a refreshing read that also gives you a peek into the world of NFL wives and girlfriends, with all the drama that comes with it.
21. The Simple Wild by K.A. Tucker
Let’s start with a bit of a different vibe. The Simple Wild isn’t exactly a sports romance, but it’s got the same emotional depth and character-driven story that you loved in Icebreaker.
It follows Calla Fletcher, who travels to the remote wilds of Alaska to reconnect with her estranged father.
There, she meets Jonah, a rugged, no-nonsense pilot who challenges her at every turn. The setting is almost a character in itself, and the romance between Calla and Jonah is slow-burn and deeply satisfying.
It’s perfect if you’re looking for something a bit more introspective but still packed with chemistry.
22. Steadfast by Sarina Bowen
Steadfast is the second book in Sarina Bowen’s True North series, and while it’s not sports-centered, it’s a beautifully written romance that delves into complex issues.
It follows Jude Nickel, a recovering addict who returns to his hometown to start over, and Sophie Haines, the girl he left behind.
Their relationship is filled with tension, guilt, and a deep connection that never really went away. The emotional intensity and character development in this book are phenomenal, making it a perfect read if you loved the emotional depth in Icebreaker.
23. The Hardest Fall by Ella Maise
If you’re into college sports romances, The Hardest Fall by Ella Maise is a great pick.
The story follows Zoe, a quirky photography major, and Dylan, a star football player.
They start off as unlikely friends after a series of awkward encounters, but their friendship quickly develops into something more.
The dialogue is witty, the chemistry is palpable, and the slow-burn romance will keep you hooked.
It’s a sweet, funny, and heartfelt story that’s perfect if you’re looking for a feel-good read.
24. Blind Side by Kandi Steiner
Blind Side is a steamy and emotional sports romance that follows Clay Johnson, a star college football player, and Giana Johnson, a music major with her own past demons.
When Clay’s world is turned upside down by a family tragedy, Giana steps in to help him cope.
The connection between them is instant, but their relationship is anything but simple.
The book deals with heavy themes but balances them with moments of levity and romance.
If you liked the emotional journey of the characters in Icebreaker, this one will resonate with you.
25. Out of the Blue by P. Dangelico
Out of the Blue is a witty, slow-burn romance that follows Harrison Duke, a former pro baseball player turned high school coach, and Faith Ferguson, a woman starting over in a small town.
Their first meeting is anything but smooth, but as they spend more time together, they begin to see each other in a new light.
The banter between them is sharp, and the gradual development of their relationship is both satisfying and realistic.
It’s perfect if you’re looking for a romance with a strong emotional core and a good dose of humor.
26. Sustained by Emma Chase
Sustained is part of the Legal Briefs series, and it’s a romance that’s as funny as it is heartfelt.
The story follows Jake Becker, a no-nonsense defense attorney, and Chelsea McQuaid, a young woman who’s suddenly responsible for her six nieces and nephews.
Jake isn’t looking for a relationship, but Chelsea and her chaotic, loveable family start to break down his walls.
This book is full of hilarious moments, sweet romance, and a lot of heart.
It’s got that same blend of humor and warmth that made Icebreaker so enjoyable.
27. Good Boy by Sarina Bowen and Elle Kennedy
Good Boy is another collaboration between Sarina Bowen and Elle Kennedy, and it’s an absolute riot.
The book follows Blake Riley, a lovable goofball and professional hockey player, and Jess Canning, who’s trying to find her footing in life.
Blake is all in from the start, but Jess is determined to keep things casual.
The chemistry between them is undeniable, and the humor is spot-on.
It’s a fun, light-hearted read with just the right amount of emotional depth, making it perfect for fans of Icebreaker.
28. The Sweet Gum Tree by Katherine Allred
The Sweet Gum Tree is a beautifully written, emotional romance that spans decades.
The story is told from the perspective of Alix French, who recounts her lifelong relationship with Nick Anderson, from their childhood friendship to their complicated adult relationship.
This book is filled with twists, heartache, and deep love.
It’s not a sports romance, but if you loved the emotional complexity and character-driven narrative of Icebreaker, you’ll find this book equally compelling.
29. The Year We Fell Down by Sarina Bowen
In The Year We Fell Down, we meet Corey Callahan, a former hockey player who’s adjusting to life in a wheelchair after a devastating accident.
She meets Adam Hartley, a fellow student and hockey player, who’s also dealing with his own injury.
They form a deep friendship that slowly blossoms into something more.
This book is a beautiful exploration of resilience, friendship, and love, with a unique sports backdrop.
It’s a bit more introspective but still has that sweet, slow-burn romance you’re craving.
30. Irresistible by Melanie Harlow
Irresistible is a delightful romance about Claire, a single mother of three, and Mack, her boss and a former Marine.
Mack is everything Claire shouldn’t want—he’s serious, gruff, and emotionally closed off.
But as they spend more time together, they start to see each other in a new light.
This book is filled with humor, heart, and plenty of steamy moments.
The slow build of their relationship and the depth of their connection make this a perfect read if you’re looking for something with both heat and heart.
31. Heart of the Game by Rachel Gibson
Heart of the Game is a sports romance that follows Kate Hamilton, a single mother who’s trying to rebuild her life, and Ty Savage, a professional baseball player who’s dealing with his own personal demons.
Their paths cross, and despite their differences, they find themselves drawn to each other.
The book explores themes of redemption, love, and second chances, all within the framework of a sports romance.
It’s emotional, steamy, and deeply satisfying.
32. Only When It’s Us by Chloe Liese
Only When It’s Us is the first book in the Bergman Brothers series and is a fantastic enemies-to-lovers romance.
The story follows Willa Sutter, a fiercely competitive college soccer player, and Ryder Bergman, a quiet, brooding guy who sits next to her in class.
When a misunderstanding turns them into rivals, the tension between them is palpable. But as they get to know each other, they start to see past their initial impressions.
This book is full of witty banter, emotional depth, and a slow-burn romance that will keep you hooked.
So there you have it— some amazing books that’ll give you the same kind of feels you got from Icebreaker.
Each one brings something a little different to the table, but they all have that mix of sports, romance, and unforgettable characters that made Hannah Grace’s book such a hit.
Whether you’re in the mood for something light and funny or a bit more intense and emotional, this list has you covered.
Grab a comfy spot, maybe some hot cocoa, and dive into these stories.
Happy reading!