Step into a world where darkness converges with raw emotion, where the sinister path of a serial killer on death row is untangled through the voices of the women who orbit his life.
In “Notes on an Execution” by Danya Kukafka, the countdown begins for Ansel Packer, a man who craves not only absolution but also an understanding that might defy the human comprehending ability.
Through the eyes of a mother driven to desperation, a sister bound by an unbreakable bond, and a relentless detective who battles her own demons, we delve into the haunting story that led to a tragedy far from the unimaginable.
In this discussion guide, we’ll have a look at some book club questions for Notes on an Execution and why it’s a must-read for anyone who is trying to understand how our upbringing and traumas surrounding us actually end up shaping us as a person whom we dread to be.
The post might contain affiliate links. For more information, read our disclosure.
Notes on an Execution Book Club Questions
- Ansel’s second-person, present-tense narration allows us to delve into his psyche and experience his distorted perception of reality. This perspective creates a sense of immediacy and intimacy, immersing the reader in Ansel’s disturbing mindset. On the other hand, the third-person perspective used for Lavender, Saffy, and Hazel provides a more objective view of their lives and the impact of Ansel’s actions on them.
What’s your take on this use of different narrative perspectives and how does it contribute to the storytelling and our understanding of the characters?
- Ansel’s childhood experiences, particularly the abusive and isolated environment created by his father Johnny Packer, played a significant role in shaping his psychopathic behavior. Lavender’s youth and lack of parental guidance, coupled with Johnny’s violent abuse towards both her and Ansel, fostered an environment that lacked stability, love, and proper nurturing.
If Ansel would have had a proper upbringing, do you think he would be in a much better state today? Also, discuss how our upbringing affects our life in ways one cannot even fathom.
- Saffy’s confrontation with Ansel shatters the illusion she had built in her head about his genius and superiority. She realizes that he is an ordinary man and that she, herself, is a woman of greater intelligence and complexity. This realization aligns with one of the novel’s central themes of deconstructing the serial killer, as Saffy discovers that Ansel’s perceived superiority was a facade.
- Saffy’s discovery of Ansel playing with the corpses of animals serves as a turning point that shatters Saffy’s innocent admiration for him. Witnessing such disturbing behavior instills a sense of fear and distrust in Saffy. Additionally, Ansel’s subsequent act of placing a dismembered fox in Saffy’s bed and issuing a threat demonstrates his manipulative and vengeful nature. This incident creates a sense of vulnerability and trauma for Saffy, leading her to distance herself from Ansel and ultimately transfer to a different care home.
Discuss how staying with someone who shows psychopathic behavior can have a long-term detrimental effect on a person, as in the case of Saffy.
- Initially infatuated with Ansel’s tragic and handsome persona, Saffy’s perception changes when she witnesses his disturbing behavior and suspects him of things one cannot even imagine. Despite facing skepticism from her colleagues in law enforcement, Saffy’s dedication to seeking the truth and ensuring that justice is served propels her forward in the right direction.
Explore Saffy’s journey from being enamored by Ansel to becoming determined to bring him to justice. What drives her to pursue him for years, and how does her character develop throughout the novel?
- Hazel’s feelings towards Ansel are complex, shaped by her perception of being the less attractive and less popular twin compared to Jenny. She is drawn to Ansel’s attention and resents Jenny for seemingly effortlessly obtaining what Hazel desires.
Analyze the role of Hazel in the story, particularly her feelings towards Ansel and her relationship with her twin sister, Jenny. How does her perspective add depth to the narrative?
- Ansel believes that if he can escape, he will never harm another person, indicating his yearning for redemption and transformation. However, the novel does not provide a straightforward answer to whether redemption is truly possible for someone like Ansel. While Ansel experiences brief moments of peace and happiness during his time with his brother’s family, his past actions and the darkness within him ultimately lead to further violence.
Consider the theme of redemption and second chances in the novel. How does Ansel’s desire to escape and start a new life relate to this theme? Does the novel suggest that redemption is possible for someone like Ansel?
- As an Indian American woman, Saffy faces the challenges and biases of a system that often favors those in positions of privilege.
Discuss Saffy’s role as a detective and her experience as an Indian American woman in a culture where white men hold power. How does this influence her pursuit of Ansel and her perception of the cases she investigates?
- Saffy’s jealousy at Ansel’s happiness at the Blue House drives her to reveal his suspected crimes to Blue and Rachel. Her jealousy stems from her unresolved trauma and the initial encounter she had with Ansel, which left a deep impact on her.
Do you think that in this case, Saffy actually struggled with separating her personal feelings from her professional duty, and her actions were partly driven by a desire to disrupt Ansel’s seemingly content life?
- Trauma plays a significant role in the novel, impacting the major characters in various ways. Ansel, for instance, experiences childhood abuse, abandonment, and the loss of his baby brother. These traumas shape him as both a victim and a victimizer. However, Kukafka critically examines the explanation that childhood trauma directly leads to adult violence. Through the characters of Lavender, Saffy, and Ansel, she explores how trauma affects individuals differently, reverberating throughout their lives.
If you liked these set of questions, here are some other options for you to explore.
Crying in H Mart: Michelle Zauner’s poignant memoir explores her journey as a Korean American, navigating cultural identity, the loss of her mother, and the pursuit of her own path. With evocative storytelling, she discovers the invaluable gifts her mother bestowed upon her amidst life’s trials and triumphs.
Cloud Cuckoo Land: A mesmerizing novel by Anthony Doerr, blending stories from different eras to explore survival and the power of storytelling. From Constantinople in 1453 to a troubled Idaho in 2020 and an uncertain future beyond that, this book celebrates hope, resilience, and the profound bonds between us.
Black Cake: In present-day California, siblings Byron and Benny inherit a black cake and a mysterious recording from their late mother. Secrets, betrayals, and a long-lost child challenge their understanding of family, history, and themselves in this captivating debut novel by Charmaine Wilkerson.
It Ends With Us: Lily, a determined and ambitious woman, finds herself captivated by the enigmatic Ryle, a brilliant neurosurgeon. But when her first love resurfaces, her newfound happiness is put to the test, and she must confront the painful choices that lie ahead.
It Starts With Us: In the highly anticipated sequel to It Ends with Us, Colleen Hoover explores Atlas’s side of the story and what happens next. Lily’s chance encounter with her first love leads to a second chance at love, but not without the challenges of a jealous ex-husband.