12 The Hotel Nantucket Book Club Questions for Discussion

ByBooks That Slay Editors Last Updated:

Elin Hilderbrand’s “The Hotel Nantucket” is not just a tale of a grand establishment. It is an intricate amalgamation of secrets, betrayals, and human connections, set against the evocative backdrop of a bustling hotel. 

As characters from varied walks of life intersect, romances bloom, old wounds are reopened, and buried secrets see the light of day, painting a vivid picture of the complexities of human interactions. 

Delving deeper into this narrative, we have curated a set of detailed book club questions for The Hotel Nantucket that aim to unravel the multifaceted relationships, societal themes, and character growths embedded within the story. 

Join us as we embark on a journey through the hallowed halls of The Hotel Nantucket, exploring each layer of Hilderbrand’s captivating world.

The Hotel Nantucket Book Club questions

The Hotel Nantucket Book Club Questions

  1. Elin Hilderbrand’s “The Hotel Nantucket” not only delves into the intricacies of interpersonal relationships but also touches on the essence of a place and its haunting past. The hotel’s haunting by Grace Hadley, who met her tragic end due to an illicit love affair, intertwines the physical space of the hotel with its emotional and historical resonance. How do the hotel’s history, embodied by Grace’s spirit, and the contemporary dynamics among the staff and guests mirror each other in themes of love, betrayal, and redemption?

  2. Throughout the novel, the motivations and aspirations of characters are intricately tied to their roles within the hotel. Characters such as Lizbet Keaton and Chadwick Winslow are seen navigating their personal turmoils while simultaneously being deeply connected to the operations and reputation of The Hotel Nantucket. In what ways does the setting of the hotel itself become a character, shaping and being shaped by the individuals within its walls?

  3. Trust and deception weave a complex web in “The Hotel Nantucket,” from Lizbet’s betrayal by JJ O’Malley to the unveiling of Kimber Marsh’s true identity as Shelly Carpenter. This theme is further amplified by the historical betrayal revealed in Jackson Benedict’s journal, showcasing that deception transcends time. Given these layers of trust issues and deception, how does the novel highlight the process of healing, forgiveness, and the resilience of the human spirit in the face of repeated betrayals?

  4. Grace’s evolution, from a forgotten and obscured figure to a recognized and celebrated presence, stands out as a particularly compelling subplot. Despite her spectral nature, Grace’s journey resonates with themes of justice, recognition, and purpose, and her interactions with the living serve as both cautionary tales and heartwarming connections.
    How does Grace’s arc of redemption and her intersections with various characters shed light on broader themes of the past’s impact on the present, as well as the search for personal justice and validation?

  5. Lizbet Keaton’s metamorphosis is at the heart of the narrative. As she evolves from being known primarily as JJ’s other half to establishing herself as a formidable force in the hotel industry, she undergoes profound internal changes. Her journey isn’t just about the external achievements but also about healing past wounds and gaining closure from traumatic experiences.
    How does the portrayal of Lizbet’s professional ascent intertwine with her personal journey of addressing past traumas and navigating new romantic prospects?

  6. The theme of Redressing Past Hauntings is pervasive throughout the novel. Grace Hadley, a ghost from 1922, becomes a poignant representation of this theme, seeking reconciliation for the injustice meted out to her. She isn’t merely a spectral presence but an entity who interacts and influences current events at the Hotel Nantucket.
    In what ways does Grace’s story, both as a historical echo and an active participant in the hotel’s modern narrative, reinforce the idea that the past must be acknowledged and reconciled before one can move forward?

  7. Chad Winslow’s character adds a layer of complexity to the narrative by challenging our understanding of privilege and atonement. Even though he is born into opulence, his journey of self-imposed penance for the accident he caused offers a stark contrast to the stereotypical portrayal of the wealthy.
    How does Chad’s determination to seek redemption through manual labor and his interactions with Bibi exemplify the novel’s exploration of personal responsibility and the challenges of overcoming class prejudice?

  8. The Hotel Nantucket isn’t just a setting; it functions as a hub where various life stories intertwine, unravel, and evolve. The hotel witnesses a myriad of personal dramas, successes, and challenges, and itself becomes a living, breathing entity where the theme of The Hotel As Exchange Hub emerges prominently.
    Considering the experiences of characters such as Lizbet, Xavier, and Magda, how does the novel position the hotel as a microcosm of society, where power dynamics, personal aspirations, and societal expectations play out?

  9. Throughout the novel, there’s a powerful juxtaposition of the tangible, physical world and the ever-evolving realm of online presence. The digital footprint and physical reality weave together, impacting relationships, self-image, and personal growth.
    How does Hilderbrand utilize the contrast between these two spheres to dissect modern-day relationship dynamics and individual identities?

  10. Characters like Alessandra Powell and Magda English present two distinct ways women navigate a world dominated by male expectations and power dynamics. While Alessandra uses her allure and relationships with powerful men as currency, Magda operates from a place of discreet wisdom and financial acumen.
    Drawing from the narratives of these two characters, how does the novel critique the varying strategies women employ to secure agency and respect in a male-centric environment?

  11. The characters within the Hotel Nantucket are often wrestling with the specters of their pasts. From Lizbet’s betrayal to Edie’s harrowing experience with her ex-boyfriend, these ghosts frequently intrude upon their present, influencing their choices and challenging their peace.
    How do these haunting memories, whether they’re recent or distant, shape the actions and decisions of Hilderbrand’s characters, and how does the hotel itself serve as a backdrop for confronting, understanding, and eventually moving past these traumas?

  12. Throughout the narrative, food and the act of cooking are not just about sustenance but are intricately tied to emotions, relationships, and love. Whether it’s Mario’s dishes that captivate Lizbet or JJ’s realization about the lack of ‘magic’ in his culinary creations post Lizbet’s departure, food serves multiple symbolic purposes.
    In what ways does Hilderbrand utilize food as a metaphor to explore the depths of human relationships, love, and betrayal in the novel?

Check our discussion questions for other books