10 The Violin Conspiracy Book Club Questions for Discussion

Join me as we unravel the mystery of a Black classical music aficionado, Ray McMillian, whose dream of becoming a professional musician is threatened when his family heirloom, a priceless Stradivarius violin, is stolen on the eve of the most prestigious classical music competition in the world. 

In “The Violin Conspiracy” by Brendan Slocumb, we follow Ray’s journey as he fights to reclaim his family’s legacy and prized possession while navigating the challenges of racism, family disputes, and societal pressures. 

Will Ray be able to retrieve his beloved violin and fulfill his lifelong dream of becoming a renowned legend in the field of classical music? 

Let’s find out together in this discussion guide where we’ll have a look at some book club questions for The Violin Conspiracy and why it’s a must-read for anyone looking to understand that artistic pursuits with a goal for excellence often finds a treacherous road ahead in the journey. 

The post might contain affiliate links. For more information, read our disclosure
The Violin Conspiracy Book Club Questions

The Violin Conspiracy Book Club Questions 

  1. The third-person point of view and past tense narrative in The Violin Conspiracy provides a sense of objectivity and retrospection for the reader. It allows us to observe Ray’s journey from an external perspective, gaining insight into his experiences, emotions, and decisions made along the way. Additionally, it also adds a reflective quality to the storytelling, creating anticipation and curiosity about how the events unfolded.
    What’s your take on this kind of narrative structure? Did you find it way more appealing than a basic linear structure? 

  2. Ray loved playing the violin from a young age but his mother eventually discouraged him from doing that, considering it was a waste of time. This conflict between Ray’s passion and his mother’s disapproval creates as sense of tension and a desire for validation as an artist.
    What’s your take on the way it showcases the challenges faced by individuals pursuing artistic passions when their families have different expectations?

  3. The discovery of Ray’s family history and the connection to his ancestor, Leon Marks, deeply impacts his perspective and musical motivations. Learning about the musical legacy in his family and the story of Leon’s enslavement, his relationship with Thomas Marks, and the violin’s significance, creates a profound sense of identity and deep fueled desire of excellence for Ray. It fuels his determination to succeed in music and reinforces the importance of reclaiming his heritage.
    Sometimes all we need is a little push to go forward with our dreams, just like in the case of Ray. Don’t you think so?

  4.  As Ray delves deeper into his musical journey, he discovers that music transcends language and serves as a powerful means of expressing emotions and connecting with different cultures and individuals. The violin becomes a conduit for Ray’s emotions and enables him to forge meaningful relationships, both personal and professional, with others who share his passion for music.
    Discuss how music has been explored as a form of communication and connection in this novel. 

  5. The relationships in The Violin Conspiracy play significant roles in Ray’s growth and self-understanding. Ray’s connection with Janice, his violin teacher at Markham University, serves as a mentorship that nurtures his talent and provides the right kind of guidance. Janice’s belief in Ray’s abilities and her support contribute to his development as a musician. Additionally, Ray’s relationship with Nicole, his girlfriend, and fellow musician, offers him the necessary emotional support and understanding during challenging times. 
    Do you think with the help of these relationships, Ray discovered the importance of surrounding oneself with those that believed in him?

  1. The Tchaikovsky Competition represented a significant milestone and a platform for Ray to showcase his talent on an international stage. Through this competition, he is able to amplify his aspirations and validate his dedication to music. While winning second prize is a remarkable achievement, the journey itself becomes a testament to his resilience, determination, and insane growth as an artist.
    Discuss how Ray’s participation in the Tchaikovsky Competition shaped his character and aspirations in the novel.

  2. When Ray discovers the truth about his violin’s ownership and suspects Nicole’s involvement in its theft, it shatters his trust and brings forth a sense of betrayal. This revelation challenges his perception of the people closest to him and creates a conflict between his emotions and his desire for justice.
    Do you think it forced Ray to confront the complexities of trust and personal boundaries, ultimately leading to his search for answers and resolution?

  3. The novel portrays the various forms of discrimination faced by Ray as a Black soloist in a white-dominated field. Throughout the story, Ray encounters prejudice from his superiors, colleagues, law enforcement, and even strangers. These instances of discrimination occur in different forms, such as people making assumptions about the type of music he plays or doubting his abilities.
    What’s your take on the way Brendan Slocumb included these small everyday moments punctuated by racism to capture the pervasive nature of discrimination in Ray’s life and the discrimination faced by certain members of a particular community?

  4. Which theme from The Violin Conspiracy did you resonate with the most?

    Resilience – Ray’s journey exemplified the resilience required to overcome obstacles and pursue his dreams, despite familial opposition and legal conflicts.
    Self-Discovery – Through the discovery of his family history and the violin’s significance, Ray embarked on a path of self-discovery, uncovering his identity and finding purpose in his musical heritage.
    Passion – The novel conveyed the message that following one’s passion and embracing personal history can lead to a deeper understanding of oneself and a fulfilling life.

  1. The novel delves into the strain that money and success have placed on Ray’s relationships, particularly with his family. The author explores complex family dynamics, highlighting the contrast between family members who genuinely care for Ray and those who only show kindness when they need something from him. For example, Aunt Rochelle consistently supports Ray and helps him when no other family members do.
    What’s your take on strained familial relationships being a recurring theme in the novel?

If you liked these set of questions, here are a few options for you to explore.

Ugly Love: When Tate meets Miles, it’s not love at first sight. All they want is a no-strings-attached arrangement. But as their desires clash with their hearts, secrets unravel and love turns messy. In this captivating tale, rules are broken, hearts are shattered and love gets ugly.

Ugly Love Book Club Questions

Surviving Savannah: Delve into the captivating tale of the steamship Pulaski, its tragic sinking, and the courageous women who grappled with heartbreaking choices. Uncover the enigmatic history, mysteries, and survival instincts that shaped their lives in this riveting exploration of human resilience and the power of fate.

Surviving Savannah Book Club Questions

The Paris Apartment: In the heart of Paris, Jess seeks solace and a fresh start, only to find her brother missing from the luxurious apartment he supposedly owns. As she delves into the secretive lives of his enigmatic neighbors, she uncovers a web of deceit and hidden truths.

The Paris Apartment Book Club Questions

The Sweetness of Water: In the aftermath of the Civil War, two freed brothers seek refuge on a grieving Georgia farmer’s homestead, forging an unexpected friendship. Meanwhile, a forbidden romance between Confederate soldiers sets off a chain of events that tests the community’s resolve. Nathan Harris’s debut novel weaves a captivating tale of love and redemption in the crucible of Reconstruction-era Georgia.

The Sweetness of Water Book Club Questions

The Push: Blythe longs to be the loving mother she never had, but when her daughter’s behavior takes a dark turn, she questions her sanity. As secrets unravel, this gripping psychological drama challenges everything you think you know about motherhood and trust.

The Push Book Club Questions