If He Had Been With Me Summary and Key Themes

A good teenage drama with a twist is what the book “If He Had Been With Me” by Laura Nowlin is all about. 

The book tells the story of Autumn and Finny, childhood friends who drift apart in high school due to certain circumstances but reconnect after their graduation. Their renewed relationship is cut short by Finny’s fatal accident, profoundly impacting Autumn’s life and mental health.

If He Had Been With Me Summary

Imagine two kids, Autumn and Finny, who’ve been besties since they were in diapers because their moms are super close. They were inseparable, but things started to change in high school. Autumn felt left out by their group of friends and started to drift away from Finny

She hung out with her new friend, Sasha, and they formed a new crew with some other kids.

Now high school is full of drama, right? 

Well, Autumn and Sasha both crush on this guy, Jamie, but Jamie ends up choosing Autumn. Meanwhile, Finny starts dating Sylvie, and Autumn can’t help but feel a bit jealous, even though she’s with Jamie. She’s always watching Finny and Sylvie together and it bothers her more than she wants to admit.

Then there’s a quirky part. 

Autumn starts wearing tiaras. 

Yep, you heard it right – tiaras, like a princess. Some people make fun of her, but her friends are cool about it and even gift her more tiaras on special occasions.

Fast forward to junior year, and things get more complicated. Autumn realizes she’s actually in love with Finny, but she’s still with Jamie and Finny is still with Sylvie. 

Tough situation, right? 

Autumn decides to follow her dream of becoming a writer instead of going for the more practical teaching career Jamie suggested.

Senior year hits and it’s a wild ride. 

Autumn and Finny end up in the same gym class and become partners for activities. They start getting close again, but then Autumn’s world starts to crumble. Her parents split up, her friend Angie gets pregnant, and right after graduation, she finds out Jamie is in love with Sasha. 


Summer arrives and it is that exact time, Autumn is really down. 

But guess what? 

Finny starts hanging out with her more, and they finally admit their feelings for each other. 

It’s like a dream come true for Autumn – until it turns into a nightmare. 

Finny decides to break up with Sylvie but gets into a horrible car accident while arguing with her. 

Sylvie survives, but Finny… doesn’t.

Autumn is shattered by Finny’s death. 

She’s so heartbroken that she tries to end her life. In the hospital, while they’re checking if she’s pregnant, she thinks about Finny’s happiness holding Angie’s baby and starts to think maybe she should live, at least long enough to have Finny’s child, if she’s pregnant.

That ended really hard, doesn’t it? 

if he had been with me summary

Also Read: The Subtle Art of Not Giving a F*ck Summary and Key Lessons

Key Themes

1. The Importance of Communication and Confronting Feelings

Throughout the novel, Autumn and Finny struggle with unspoken feelings and misunderstandings. Their inability to communicate openly about their emotions leads to years of heartache and missed opportunities. 

This emphasizes the vital role of honest communication in relationships. The story serves as a lesson that expressing one’s true feelings, even when it feels risky or uncomfortable, can prevent misunderstandings and foster deeper connections. 

It underscores the idea that open dialogue is essential for the health and longevity of any relationship, whether it be romantic, platonic, or familial.

2. Navigating the Complexities of Adolescent Relationships

The novel realistically portrays the complexities and evolving nature of relationships during adolescence. As characters transition from childhood to adulthood, their relationships undergo significant changes. This includes the dynamics between friends, romantic interests, and family members. 

The story illustrates how adolescent relationships are often a mix of confusion, intensity, and emotional upheaval, highlighting the need for empathy and patience. It also touches on the idea that people change over time, and what we want or need in relationships can evolve. 

This lesson can help young adults understand that it’s natural for relationships to change as they grow and that it’s important to adapt to these changes healthily.

Also Read: When The Body Says No Summary and Key Lessons

3. Dealing with Loss and Mental Health Challenges

The tragic events in the book, including Finny’s death and Autumn’s subsequent mental health struggles, bring attention to the themes of grief, loss, and mental health. 

Autumn’s journey through depression and suicidal ideation emphasizes the importance of seeking support in times of emotional distress. 

It also opens a discussion on how young adults cope with extreme emotions and trauma. 

The story serves as a reminder that mental health is crucial and seeking help from friends, family, or mental health professionals is not a sign of weakness but of strength. 

Furthermore, it illustrates the long-term impact of loss and the importance of grief processing, offering insight into the complexities of emotional recovery after a traumatic event.

Final Thoughts

This book isn’t just about a high school romance; it’s about dealing with real, tough emotions and situations that many of us face in life. Love, loss, friendship, and finding your way through the darkest times. A rollercoaster of feelings that anyone, especially at 18, can relate to in one way or another.

So, if you’re up for a story that’s both heartwarming and heartbreaking, with characters that feel incredibly real, “If He Had Been With Me” is definitely worth the read. 

It’s a vivid look into the complexities of teenage life and love, with a powerful reminder of how precious and unpredictable life is.

Read our other summaries: