Step into the shadows of a hidden London alley, where secrets fester and vengeance takes root. In a clandestine apothecary shop, Nella awaits her latest customer, harboring a dark purpose.
Once a healer, now a dispenser of disguised poisons, she liberates women from the clutches of their wrongdoers. But when a curious young girl named Eliza seeks her help, an unlikely friendship kindles, setting forth a perilous chain of events.
Centuries later, as historian Caroline’s world crumbles, an enigmatic apothecary vial links her to a haunting mystery. As their destinies intertwine, lives hang in the balance.
Brace yourself for “The Lost Apothecary” and its captivating collision of past and present.
In this discussion guide, we will have a look at some amazing book club questions for The Lost Apothecary and why it’s a must-read for anyone looking to understand why revenge often has repercussions one can’t even imagine.
The post might contain affiliate links. For more information, read our disclosure. Also, these questions contain spoilers.
The Lost Apothecary Book Club Questions For Discussion
- The characters in The Lost Apothecary exhibit diverse perspectives and experiences with regard to themes of betrayal, feminine power, and secrecy, allowing us to see a broad range of responses to societal pressures. Nella, for instance, is driven to her apothecary trade by betrayal, and operates within a strict code to protect and empower women, while keeping her work a super secret.
What’s your take on the way these three themes interact and intersect in Nella’s character development? Also, what do her actions and choices reveal about the societal expectations and limitations for women during her time period?
- Sarah Penner uses a dual timeline in the novel to compare and contrast the experiences of women across centuries. While there are many similarities, the differences are evident as well: Nella and Eliza, living in 1791, face severe societal restrictions and dangers that lead them into situations of desperation and danger, while Caroline, in the present day, has greater freedom and options than her respective counterparts.
How does the use of dual timelines and alternating points of view help us understand the historical context of women’s struggles, and in what ways does it emphasize the progress made, or lack thereof, in women’s rights and societal status between the 18th century and present day?
- The artifact of the vial found by Caroline in the Thames River serves as a link between the past and the present in the novel. This small, seemingly insignificant object sets Caroline on a path of discovery, leading her to uncover the hidden history of Nella and Eliza.
Based on this context, how does Caroline’s investigation into the vial’s origin illustrate the act of uncovering hidden or forgotten histories?
- In the novel, each of the three main characters grapples with the aftermath of personal betrayals. Nella was betrayed by Frederick, Eliza was betrayed by her employer, and Caroline was betrayed by her husband.
In what ways does the novel explore the personal and societal consequences of these betrayals, and how do these experiences of betrayal inform the actions and decisions of Nella, Eliza, and Caroline?
- Nella Clavinger is depicted as a woman who has endured intense personal suffering and ultimately channels her pain into a form of vigilantism, targeting oppressive men and aiding the women who have suffered under them. Given her tragic history, she becomes a purveyor of poisons in response to her ex-lover, Frederick’s deception and the harm he inflicted upon her.
Do you think there that every woman on Earth has traits that Nella Clavinger has, provided she has suffered as much as Nella has?
- Throughout the novel, Eliza develops from a young, naive maid to an essential player in Nella’s operations. She starts having a strong influence on Nella’s decision-making, particularly regarding Lady Clarence’s request. Her transformation is significant, and despite the hardships she experiences, she becomes a symbol of resilience and adaptability.
What’s your take on Eliza’s character development in the novel and how does it reflect on the themes of survival and self-determination in adverse circumstances?
- Eliza Fanning is characterized by her hope and belief in the power of the mystical, offering a stark contrast to Nella’s more grounded and pragmatic approach to the world. Her faith in the magical Tincture to Reverse Bad Fortune and her subsequent handling of the fallout from Lord Clarence’s death highlights her youthful optimism and resilience.
How does Eliza’s youthful optimism, embodied by her belief in magic, influence her decisions and relationships, particularly with Nella, throughout the novel?
- The character of Mr. Amwell serves as a manifestation of the oppressive and dangerous patriarchal society that Nella, Eliza, and other women in the novel must navigate. He is depicted as a flat character with no redeeming qualities, serving as a source of horror and distress for Eliza.
What’s your take on this portrayal of Mr. Amwell’s character and how did it contribute to the novel’s exploration of patriarchy, gender dynamics, and the concept of justice?
- The novel explores the manifestation of feminine power in the Georgian era, a patriarchal epoch that offered very little autonomy to women. Nella and Eliza serve as prime examples of women in the Georgian era who resist conventional gender roles, utilizing their limited control to exert broader influence over their lives.
How do Nella and Eliza’s individual paths of resistance illuminate the different ways in which women were able to exercise their power, and how does their portrayal challenge or adhere to the societal norms of the Georgian era?
- The theme of feminine power extends beyond the individual to the domestic sphere, with characters like Lady Clarence exerting control over their domestic lives in an attempt to manipulate their destinies. The theme is in contrast to the patriarchal social structure of the Georgian era, providing a nuanced understanding of the female mind and wishes as a whole.
Discuss how Lady Clarence’s deeds illustrate the struggles and limitations of female agency within the domestic sphere and how does this relate to the broader theme of feminine power in patriarchal societies as portrayed in the novel.
If you liked these questions, here are a few other options for you to explore.
The Push: In “The Push,” Blythe’s dream of being a loving mother turns into a nightmare as she suspects something is wrong with her daughter. Is it all in her head, or is there a chilling truth lurking? A gripping, mind-bending exploration of motherhood and the power of belief.
The Sweetness of Water: A profound debut by Nathan Harris, set during the Civil War’s end, weaving the lives of freedmen brothers, a grieving Georgia farmer, and a forbidden romance, revealing the transformative power of friendship, love, and healing in the midst of harrowing circumstances.
While Justice Sleeps: Law clerk Avery Keene is thrust into a dangerous game when she becomes the guardian and power of attorney for her comatose boss, Justice Wynn. As she unravels his cryptic clues, Avery uncovers a conspiracy that reaches the highest levels of power in Washington. A gripping, suspenseful tale by Stacey Abrams.
Wish You Were Here: In the face of an unexpected crisis, Diana’s carefully planned life takes a drastic turn. Stranded on an island under quarantine, she embarks on a transformative journey, forging unlikely connections and questioning the person she will become upon her return home.
The Silent Patient: Alicia Berenson, a renowned artist, shoots her husband in the face and never speaks again. Psychotherapist Theo Faber is determined to unravel her mystery, leading him down a dangerous path in this gripping psychological thriller.