Welcome to a neighborhood where everyone seems to have a secret buried underground.
L. Alison Heller’s “The Neighbor’s Secret” takes you on a thrilling ride through the seemingly perfect suburban community of Cottonwood Estates where beneath the lush lawns and friendly hellos of a club filled with bibliophiles, lies a web of dark secrets waiting to be uncovered.
As acts of vandalism begin to target the women of this book club, they are forced to confront their pasts and decide just how far they will have to go to protect their families.
In this discussion guide, we’ll have a look at some book club questions for The Neighbor’s Secret and why it’s a must-read for anyone looking for a thrilling and thought-provoking page-turner on how the secrets that lure behind closed doors often end up affecting our lives in ways we cannot imagine.
The post might contain affiliate links. For more information, read our disclosure. Also, these questions contain spoilers.
The Neighbor’s Secret Book Club Questions
- The book portrays suburban life to be characterized by a veneer of perfection that hides a great deal of dysfunction and hidden secrets. The characters in the novel are all trying to present a picture of success and contentment, but beneath the surface, they are struggling with issues like mental illness, addiction, and abuse.
What’s your take on the way the dark side of suburban life is portrayed in this novel?
- Jen’s denial about her son’s behavior is a major factor in the events that unfold in the novel. Her refusal to accept that Abe might be a sociopath leads her to make decisions that put not only her but others in danger as well. She was so afraid of facing the truth that she ended up ignoring warning signs and even lying to herself about Abe’s behavior.
Do you think if Jen would have been more honest with herself, she could have avoided the eventual violent confrontation at the later stages of the story?
- What is your take on the main purpose of the mentioned book club in the novel?
– Allowing women to discuss the issues affecting their personal lives
– Providing a kind of roadmap for future events via interpersonal discussions
– Providing a context for the author to explore some of the key themes of the novel, such as the secrets that people keep from one another and the dangers of denial.
- Lena’s reclusiveness takes an enigmatic approach in a reader’s mind while reading the novel. It provides a kind of mystery that keeps the reader engaged and curious about Lena’s past, apart from serving as a contrast to the other characters, who are all trying to hide their secrets from one another.
What’s your take on the way Lena’s secret impacts the latter half of the story?
- While the adults are struggling to maintain their façade of success and contentment, the teenagers in the novel are more open and honest about their feelings and motivations. However, they are also more impulsive and unpredictable, with their actions serving to expose the weaknesses and vulnerabilities of the adults.
Discuss the way the roles of both adults and teenagers have been combined in order to provide more depth and twists to the story.
- Secrets and hidden relationships play a major role in the story, driving much of the plot and character development. From Laurel and Sierra’s drunken escapades to Annie’s affair with Lena’s husband and Bryce Neary, the novel is filled with secrets that threaten to unravel the characters’ lives.
Discuss the way these hidden relationships and the characters’ past actions create tension and conflict between them and contribute to their overall sense of guilt and shame.
- Annie’s embarrassment and shame over Laurel’s behavior at the food fest lead her to punish her daughter, while Laurel’s rebellion and sense of independence drive her to seek out new relationships and experiences. Nan Small’s focus on maintaining the school’s reputation and avoiding a scandal causes her to overlook and ignore warning signs about Abe’s behavioral disorder, while Jen’s maternal instincts lead her to be more protective and concerned about her son’s behavior.
What’s your take on the way the characters’ different perspectives and experiences shape their development throughout the novel?
- The different plotlines and subplots intersect and contribute to the overall story by providing a complex and nuanced portrait of the characters and their relationships. The novel’s various plotlines, including the mystery surrounding Bryce Neary’s death, the relationships between the characters, and the struggles of the different families, all contribute to the novel’s themes of guilt, shame, and redemption, as well as its sense of suspense and intrigue.
Which of these three themes can you resonate with the most and why?
- The unraveling of the seemingly perfect families in the book suggests that appearances can be deceiving and that even the most successful or high-achieving families can have hidden issues and secrets that eventually come to light. It also highlights the pressure that children may feel to maintain a perfect image and the consequences that can arise when they are unable to do so.
- The ending reveals much about the characters and their relationships, tying up some loose ends while leaving others unresolved. It suggests that while some characters, like Annie and Laurel, may find a sense of redemption and closure, others, like Lena and Rachel, may continue to struggle with guilt and shame. The ending also raises questions about the future of the characters and their relationships, leaving room for more interpretation and speculation, if the book ever sees a sequel.
What’s your take on the ending of the novel? Did you feel it was a challenging read when it comes to the suspense and mystery genre?
If you liked this set of questions, here are few other options for you to explore:
Wrong Place Wrong Time: In a gripping tale of desperation and second chances, a parent is caught in a chilling time loop, waking up each day before their son commits a heinous murder. With the power to change fate, they embark on a relentless quest to uncover the truth and save their son’s future.
A Gentleman in Moscow: Step into the enchanting world of Count Alexander Rostov, a witty and indomitable aristocrat confined to house arrest in a luxurious Moscow hotel. Amidst the tumultuous backdrop of Russian history, he embarks on a captivating journey of self-discovery and finding the true purpose of life.
The Maid: Follow the story of socially awkward Molly Gray, a hotel maid with an obsessive love for cleaning and etiquette. When she stumbles upon a murder scene, her peculiarities make her the prime suspect. With unexpected allies, Molly embarks on a heartwarming journey to unravel the truth. A captivating blend of mystery, humanity, and connection.
Demon Copperhead: In the rugged mountains of Appalachia, a boy fights against the odds, navigating foster care, addiction, and heartbreak. This gritty and inspiring tale, echoing Dickens’ spirit, follows a new generation of lost boys who defy their destiny in a hauntingly beautiful yet forsaken land.
Tomorrow and Tomorrow and Tomorrow: Two childhood friends, Sam and Sadie, embark on a thrilling journey in the world of video game design. Their collaboration brings fame, joy, and heartbreak, as they navigate success, duplicity, and the quest for immortality. An extraordinary love story unlike any other.